East Cobb Elections Preview: District 3 Cobb Board of Commissioners

District 3 Cobb Commission, District 3 Cobb Board of Commissioners
From L-R: Republican incumbent JoAnn Birrell; Democratic challenger Caroline Holko

The District 3 Cobb Board of Commissioners race gives voters a distinct choice.

Republican commissioner JoAnn Birrell, first elected in 2010, is a conservative from Northeast Cobb who has cited her votes against tax increases, her work to improve blighted properties in the Canton Road corridor and her push to build Mabry Park.

Democrat Caroline Holko, a first-time candidate, is an admitted “progressive” liberal who favors expanding transit options in Cobb, has been critical of the county’s Atlanta Braves stadium deal and supports more hours for services like libraries.

Birrell, a former lobbyist and consultant, said she brings “a wealth of knowledge and experience to the table.”

Holko, whose family moved to Cobb from New Orleans and who home-schools her children, said “it’s time to do things differently.”

District 3 includes much of Northeast Cobb and portions of the city of Marietta and the area around Kennesaw State University.

Birrell and Holko easily won their respective primaries in May.

Candidates homepages

Birrell and Holko met recently at a forum sponsored by the League of Women Voters of Cobb-Marietta, and discussed the above issues and others. Joseph Pond, who ran against Birrell in the 2014 Republican primary, and who is running as an independent write-in candidate, was not invited.

Birrell, who supported the Braves stadium financing in 2013, said she understands why people are still upset by that vote, “but I can’t say I regret the decision.”

She cited a recent Cobb Chamber of Commerce fiscal impact study claiming an $18.9 million annual revenue benefit for the county.

Joseph Pond
Write-in candidate Joseph Pond

Holko noted a recent vote by the commissioners to settle a dispute with the Braves over infrastructure costs.

“I would like to see the entire contract laid bare to the public so we don’t get surprises like this,” she said.

Birrell responded that the Braves-Cobb contract “is an open record” and includes a provision for disputes like this one that go to mediation.

Pond, an East Cobb resident who has clashed with the county over his backyard chickens, is a plumber and organizer of the Backyard Chickens Alliance.

He thinks commissioner seats should be non-partisan and wants to reduce county building code that’s now around 1,400 pages long. Pond also is critical of “corporate welfare,” specifically tax breaks for companies that move to Cobb.

At the League of Women Voters forum, Birrell and Holko supported the acquisition of more green space.

Holko is an unabashed supporter of more transit options. Birrell said that “we need to look at everything,” especially with a county transit study being completed by the end of the year that “will give input to where transit is needed,” followed by a referendum.

Birrell supports the creation of a special tax district to fund Cobb Police operations, similar to what is done for fire and emergency services. Holko said she supports better salaries for public safety employees.

Cobb BOC District 3 mapHolko also said she is in favor of opening libraries seven days a week, as recently was begun at regional libraries, and she prefers a neighborhood branch concept to a regional branch concept.

Birrell said the regional library concept “has been around for a long time.” She also said she wouldn’t support closing smaller branches that aren’t close to a regional library.

Holko said she’s proud to be a liberal Democrat, and that “one thing I would be on the board is [provide] a little bit of balance.”

Birrell touted her record of keeping taxes low while preserving “our quality of life . . . If you’re asking for someone who can get things done, my record speaks for itself. I do get results.”

Related coverage

 

Get Our Free E-Mail Newsletter!

Every Sunday we round up the week’s top headlines and preview the upcoming week in the East Cobb News Digest. Click here to sign up, and you’re good to go!

East Cobb Elections Update: Primary results certified; precinct breakdowns

East Cobb Election Update, JoAnn Birrell, Caroline Holko
Democrat Caroline Holko (right) got more votes than Republican incumbent JoAnn Birrell (left) in the Cobb Commission District 3 primary. But more GOP voters cast ballots in that race on May 22.

Here’s an East Cobb elections update, with official tallies from the Cobb Board of Elections and Registration, which this week certified the results of the May 22 primaries. We’ve provided the official numbers below of East Cobb-area races, but here are a few other figures of note:

  • A total of 84,284 Cobb voters cast ballots, a turnout of 17.8 percent of the 473,356 registered voters in the county;
  • More Cobb voters voted for Republican candidates at the top of the statewide ticket (governor, lieutenant governor, secretary of state, etc.) than for Democrats, but only by a slight margin, around 42,000 to around 41,000 on average.

Cobb Commission District 3

  • Caroline Holko (D): 5,767
  • JoAnn Birrell (R, incumbent): 5,634
  • Tom Cheek (R): 3,973
  • James Smith (D): 1,393

Cobb School Board Post 4

  • David Chastain (R, incumbent): 4,600
  • Cynthia Parr (D): 3,469

Cobb School Board Post 6

  • Scott Sweeney (R, incumbent): 4,844
  • Charisse Davis (D): 4,562

State Senate District 32

  • Kay Kirkpatrick (R, incumbent): 11,994
  • Christine Triebsch (D): 8,502

State House District 37

  • Sam Teasley (R, incumbent): 3,012
  • Mary Frances Williams (D): 1,964
  • Ragin Edwards (D): 514
  • Bill Bolton (D): 327

State House District 43

  • Sharon Cooper (R, incumbent): 3,034
  • Luisa Wakeman (D): 2,641

State House District 44

  • Don Parsons (R, incumbent): 2,953
  • Chinita Allen (D): 2,373
  • Homer Crothers (R): 760

State House District 45

  • Matt Dollar (R, incumbent): 3,834
  • Essence Johnson (D): 2,597

State House District 46

  • John Carson (R, incumbent): 2,788
  • Karín Sandiford (D): 1,881

U.S. House District 6

  • Karen Handel (R, incumbent): 13,996
  • Lucy McBath (D): 4,226
  • Kevin Abel (D): 3,019
  • Bobby Kaple (D): 2,762
  • Steven K. Griffin (D): 740

These are Cobb voting totals only; there will be a Democratic runoff on July 24 between McBath and Abel. There will be Republican runoff the same day in the governor’s race between current Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle and current Secretary of State Brian Kemp.

The Cobb precinct-by-precinct voting totals can be found here. Several East Cobb precincts had higher than 20 percent turnout:

  • Addison, 23.4 percent;
  • Blackwell, 20 percent;
  • Chattahoochee, 20 percent;
  • Chestnut Ridge, 23 percent;
  • Dickerson, 23 percent;
  • Dodgen, 24 percent;
  • Davis, 21 percent;
  • Eastside 1, 25 percent
  • Eastside 2, 26.8 percent;
  • Elizabeth 2, 21 percent;
  • Elizabeth 3, 23.5 percent;
  • Elizabeth 5, 21 percent;
  • Fullers Park, 21.87 percent;
  • Garrison Mill, 23.64 percent;
  • Gritters, 20.23 percent;
  • Hightower, 22 percent;
  • Lassiter, 20 percent;
  • Mabry, 21.61 percent;
  • Murdock, 23 percent;
  • McCleskey, 24 percent;
  • Marietta 6B, 23 percent;
  • Mt. Bethel 1, 22.61 percent;
  • Mt. Bethel 3, 21.95 percent;
  • Mt. Bethel 4, 23.56 percent;
  • Pope, 20 percent;
  • Roswell 1, 22 percent;
  • Sandy Plains, 20 percent;
  • Shallowford Falls, 22.65 percent;
  • Sope Creek 1, 28.29 percent;
  • Sope Creek 3, 22.79 percent;
  • Timber Ridge, 23.84 percent;
  • Willeo, 23.21 percent.

 

Get Our Free E-Mail Newsletter!

Every Sunday we round up the week’s top headlines and preview the upcoming week in the East Cobb News Digest. Click here to sign up, and you’re good to go!

East Cobb Primary Election Results: Birrell wins Cobb Commission District 3 GOP nomination

East Cobb Primary Election Results
The voting precinct at Eastside Baptist Church. The final hours of primary voting Tuesday were soggy, as a late afternoon rain storm swept through East Cobb. (East Cobb News photo by Wendy Parker)

UPDATED, 11:30 P.M.:

Cobb Commissioner JoAnn Birrell has fended off a challenge from Tom Cheek to win the Republican primary in District 3.

Birrell received 5,422 votes, or 58.48 percent, to 3,850 votes for Cheek, or 41.52 percent.

That’s with 98 percent of the vote, as tabulated by the Georgia Secretary of State’s office at 11:09 p.m.

In November, Birrell will face Caroline Holko, a first-time candidate, who easily won the Democratic primary. Holko received 5,643 votes, or 80.69 percent, to 1,350 votes for Jim Smith, or 19.31 percent.

Birrell, first elected in 2010, ran on a platform of opposing tax increases, helping spur redevelopment of the Canton Road corridor and working to establish Mabry Park.

Cheek, a critic of former commission chairman Tim Lee for his handling of the Atlanta Braves stadium deal, campaigned for SPLOST reform, reduced county spending and limiting high-density development.

Holko is a home-schooling mother and liberal political advocate who supports greater transit options in Cobb. She also is opposed to cuts for Cobb libraries and senior services. Smith is a retired Cobb-Marietta water system employee who pushed for greater salary increases for county employees.

Disrict 3 includes some of Northeast Cobb, as well as the Town Center and Kennesaw areas and much of the city of Marietta.

Final results in two contested East Cobb-area legislative races are incomplete as of 11:30 p.m., as is the Democratic primary for the 6th Congressional District race, which may be going to a runoff.

In the Democratic primary for the 6th Congressional District, Lucy McBath has 37 percent of the vote, Kevin Abel 33 percent, Bobby Kaple 24 percent and Steven Knight Griffin 5 percent.

But that’s only the advance voting totals and a few precincts reporting in a district that includes East Cobb, North Fulton and North DeKalb. The winner will face U.S. Rep. Karen Handel, a Republican, in November.

There also are only very early results in House District 44, where State Rep. Don Parsons, a Republican, was being challenged by Homer Crothers in GOP balloting.

Parsons had 2,835 votes, or 79.36 percent, to 742 for Crothers, or 20.74 percent. The winner faces Democrat Chinita Allen in November.

In State House District 37, Marietta activist Mary Frances Williams had 1,938 votes, or 70.27 percent, in the Democratic primary. Trailing were Ragin Edwards with 501 votes, or 18.17 percent, and Bill Bolton with 319 votes, or 11.57 percent.

The winner faces Republican incumbent Sam Teasley in November.

More coverage is coming on Wednesday, once the final results are in, as is a detailed look at the District 3 voting.

In Cobb commission District 1 in north and west Cobb, Republican incumbent Bob Weatherford is headed for a runoff against Kelli Gambrill.

In the governor’s race, former Georgia House Minority leader Stacey Abrams easily won the Democratic nomination over Cobb former State Rep. Stacey Evans, by a 76-24 percent margin.

Abrams becomes the first woman to become a major party nominee for Georgia governor, and the first African-American woman nationwide to win a major party nomination for governor.

Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle and Secretary of State Brian Kemp appear headed for a runoff in the Republican primary on July 24.

The Georgia Secretary of State’s has state election results that are sortable by race, county and more. Follow this link for Cobb election results.

UPDATED, 10:48 P.M.:

Cobb commissioner JoAnn Birrell has pulled away from challenger Tom Cheek in the Republican Party primary for District 3, which includes some of Northeast Cobb.

With 87 percent of precincts reporting, she has received 4,909 votes, or 58.61 percent of the vote. Cheek has 3,466 votes, or 41.39 percent.

Caroline Holko is easily winning the Democratic primary with 4,981 votes, or 80.52 percent, to 1,205 votes for Jim Smith, for 19.48 percent.

UPDATED, 9:56 P.M.

Nearly half the vote has been counted in the Cobb Commission District 3 elections.

With 44 percent of precincts reporting, incumbent JoAnn Birrell’s lead in the GOP primary has shrunk only slightly. She has 3,077 votes, or 58.76 percent, to 2,160 votes for Tom Cheek, or 41.24 percent.

Caroline Holko continues to lead easily in the Democratic primary. She has 3,002 votes, or 79.97 percent, to 752 votes for Jim Smith, or 20.03 percent.

UPDATED, 8:53 P.M.

The first results from local Cobb races are being reported. In Cobb Commission District 3, incumbent JoAnn Birrell leads Tom Cheek 60 percent-40 percent in the Republican primary.

Birrell has 761 votes to 496 for Cheek in advance voting totals.

On the Democratic side, Caroline Holko leads James Smith 80-20 percent, or 686 to 168 votes.

UPDATED, 7:36 P.M.

Some advance and absentee voting results are rolling in for statewide offices. Casey Cagle and Brian Kemp are the early leaders in the Republican primary for governor, while Stacey Abrams is leading Stacey Evans on the Democratic side.

ORIGINAL REPORT, POSTED AT 7:01 P.M.:

East Cobb voters went to the polls today to choose party nominees for a variety of offices, including Cobb Commission District 3, the 6th Congressional District, several legislative races and as well as governor and other statewide offices.

The most closely watched race in East Cobb is District 3 on the Cobb Commission, where Republican incumbent JoAnn Birrell is being challenged by Tom Cheek in the GOP primary. The winner will face the winner of the Democratic primary between Jim Smith and Caroline Holko.

A Democratic runoff for the 6th Congressional District seat is possible, with Kevin Abel, Steven Knight Griffin, Bobby Kaple and Lucy McBath vying to challenge Republican U.S. Rep. Karen Handel in November.

State Rep. Sharon Cooper, a Republican, was being challenged in the primary by Kevin James, but he was disqualified on Friday.

Voters also chose from a number of non-partisan candidates for various state and local judgeships.

A Republican runoff in the governor’s race is likely, with Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle and Secretary of State Brian Kemp leading in some late polls. On the Democratic side, former state House minority leader Stacey Abrams of Atlanta was leading former State Rep. Stacey Evans of Cobb.

Other races included lieutenant governor, secretary of state, attorney general, and state labor, insurance, agriculture and public service commissioners, as well as state school superintendent.

Democrats were also voting on straw poll questions on gun bump stock sales, Medicaid expansion, transit funding and an independent redistricting commission.

Turnout was projected to be less than 20 percent across Cobb County.

Related story

 

Get Our Free E-Mail Newsletter!

Every Sunday we round up the week’s top headlines and preview the upcoming week in the East Cobb News Digest. Click here to sign up, and you’re good to go!

Candidates on the Issues: Cobb Commission District 3

Cobb Commission District 3 map
Cobb Elections map

This is part of a week-long series of posts on East Cobb News about candidates in the May 22 primaries where there are contested party races. This post includes information about those vying for Cobb Commission District 3.

There are two Republicans and two Democrats on the primary ballot. District 3 includes most of Northeast Cobb, the Town Center Mall area and a good bit of the city of Marietta. It has been redrawn since the Republican incumbent, JoAnn Birrell, was first elected in 2010.

JoAnn BIrrell
Cobb Commissioner JoAnn Birrell

Birrell, a former lobbyist and consultant, is seeking her third term. She is touting her record against tax hikes, greater support for public safety and advocating redevelopment of the Canton Road corridor and the creation of Mabry Park.

She voted to cut the millage rate in 2016, and said she does not support raising the property tax millage rate to help solve Cobb estimated $30 million to $55 million budget for fiscal year 2019.

Birrell has advocated for the creation of a special one-cent sales tax earmarked for the Cobb Police Department, similar to what exists for the Cobb Fire Department, with a corresponding reduction in the general fund millage rate. No state legislation for a referendum was submitted.

Last year, Birrell came under fire for proposing the closure of the East Cobb Library, which is on the potential closing list again this year.

Tom Cheek

Her GOP opponent is Tom Cheek, an account manager for a software firm that services the restaurant industry. He recently moved into the district from West Cobb and was a vocal critic of former Cobb commission Chairman Tim Lee regarding his handling of the Atlanta Braves stadium deal.

Cheek has campaigned on reforming SPLOST, reducing county spending and curbing development that doesn’t conform to the land use plan.

He’s also fought the county on reforming the Cobb Medical Examiner’s Office and filed suit against Cobb in 2016, claiming a pedestrian bridge to SunTrust Park was improperly earmarked with 2016 SPLOST funds.

His SPLOST proposal calls for having a referendum to remove what he calls “infeasible” projects on the 2016 SPLOST.

Cheek also opposes TODs, or “transit-oriented developments” along Highway 41 and is skeptical of a state law passed this year creating a new metro Atlanta transit authority.

Caroline Holko
Caroline Holko

At a recent candidates forum, he also said he wants to see more detailed figures about how big the county budget gap really is.

Home-schooling mother Caroline Holko is running as a Democrat, and she admits to having liberal views in what’s regarded as a conservative district.

She supports greater transit options for Cobb citizens and is not opposed to raising the millage rate in paying for services such as libraries and senior services, saying raising the millage rate by 1 mill would cost the owner of a $250,000 home an extra $100 a year.

At a candidates forum this month, she said “I don’t really support any significant budget cuts.” Holko also has asked for an audit of the Cobb Tax Assessors office. She has said her support for a property tax increase is predicated on “realistic property assessments.”

Jim Smith, Cobb Commission District 3 candidate
Jim Smith

Retired Cobb County-Marietta Water Authority manager Jim Smith, who has been involved with the Canton Road Neighors civic group, is the other Democrat, and like Holko he is a first-time candidate.

In the campaign he has been vocal about paying county employees better. “We’re trying to do more with less,” he said at a campaign forum this month. “We’re not giving people a living wage and benefits to keep them here.”

Smith has been critical of Birrell’s and Cheek’s opposition to raising taxes, and on his Facebook page has detailed delays in road repairs as an example of lagging county services due to tight spending.

Related coverage

 

Get Our Free E-Mail Newsletter!

Every Sunday we round up the week’s top headlines and preview the upcoming week in the East Cobb News Digest. Click here to sign up, and you’re good to go!

Cobb commission District 3 candidates discusses taxes, budget deficits and more at civic forum

Three of the four Cobb commission District 3 candidates on the May 22 primary ballot turned out Tuesday night for a wide-ranging forum in Marietta, and explained their views on the county budget, spending and taxes, traffic and transit, zoning and development and other issues.

Tom Cheek, Cobb commission District 3 candidates
Tom Cheek

The only candidate not present was the person who currently holds that Northeast Cobb seat. Republican JoAnn Birrell, who is running for her third term, was a no-show at the forum, which was sponsored by the Cobb County Civic Coalition.

The other sitting commissioner seeking re-election, Republican Bob Weatherford of District 1 in West Cobb, also was absent.

The event was moderated by Dick Yarbrough, a columnist for The Marietta Daily Journal.

The two Democratic District 3 candidates, James Smith and Caroline Holko, said they favored raising the millage rate to solve the county’s estimated $30 million budget deficit for fiscal year 2019.

Birrell’s primary opponent, civic activist and software account manager Tom Cheek, who described himself as a “ferocious taxpayer advocate,” said he wants to see more detailed figures about how big the budget gap really is.

“No one has convinced me of the accuracy” of the projected budget deficit, he said in response to an audience question posed to all the candidates. “Until we get a grip on proper budgeting . . . I’m not ready to give up the millage rate we have now.”

Cheek advocates taking unused SPLOST dollars for lower-tier projects and placing them in the general fund budget (via a referendum process), looking to privatize some government functions and getting out of “the parking deck business . . . the golf course business . . . and the [Braves] stadium security business.”

Caroline Holko
Caroline Holko

The Cobb general fund millage rate is currently 6.76, a figure that was lowered in 2016. Birrell, who has said she does not favor increasing property taxes, voted for that reduction.

Smith, a retired Cobb County-Marietta Water Authority manager who’s involved with the Canton Road Neighbors civic group, frequently cited the lack of pay raises and benefits for county workers in his remarks about taxes.

He noted that salaries for Cobb firefighters and police officers are 12 and 17 percent, respectively, below the national average. “We’re trying to do more with less,” he said. “We’re not giving people a living wage and benefits to keep them here.”

While Cobb rightfully touts itself as having one of the lowest tax rates in the metro Atlanta area, Smith said, “but at what cost?”

Cheek also noted that a starting full-time police officer’s salary in Cobb is less than the pay for a part-time county commissioner, and he would work to change that.

Holko, a former non-profit administrator and home-schooling mother with liberal views, admitted she doesn’t come from a “traditional political background” in a conservative district. She advocates more transit options for Cobb citizens, and opposes proposed cuts in the Cobb library system and increases in fees for senior services.

James Smith, Cobb commission District 3 candidates
James Smith

Holko said raising the property tax rate one mill would cost an average Cobb homeowner around $100 more a year. “I can blow that in Target in about five minutes,” she said.

She and her family moved to Cobb from New Orleans several years ago, attracted by the tax rate but also the services they provide.

However, she said, “to watch that continued to be chipped away at is heartbreaking.”

When asked to specify how she would cut the budget, she said “I don’t really support any significant budget cuts.”

Smith said he would like to see the line items in county government departments, and it’s “darn near impossible” to get that information now.

Cobb commission chairman Mike Boyce, a Republican from East Cobb, has suggested a 1.1-mills increase but hasn’t released a full budget proposal. He’s scheduled budget town hall meetings for next month, with budget adoption in July.

Related stories

On the subject of transit, Holko urged the marketing budget for CobbLinc be increased “so people know it exists.”

Smith said that “whatever we do needs to go to a referendum.” Cheek is more doubtful increasing transit, citing heavy costs and a small ridership for commuting. He’s also skeptical of a new state law to create a new Atlanta-area regional transit authority.

The candidates agreed on the need for greater transparency and on zoning and development and sticking to the land use plan, and concurred that stipulation letters agreed to by developers should not be used to circumvent the county code.

District 1 challengers Kelli Gambrill and Forrest Shealy also participated in the forum.

Advance voting began in Cobb on Monday, and continues through May 18.

 

Get Our Free E-Mail Newsletter!

Every Sunday we round up the week’s top headlines and preview the upcoming week in the East Cobb News Digest. Click here to sign up, and you’re good to go!

Cobb commission candidates forum slated for Tuesday

This week may be your only occasion to hear all Cobb commission candidates in one place, in both parties, before the May 22 primaries.

There’s a forum sponsored by the Cobb County Civic Coalition Tuesday, and Democratic and Republican candidates for District 3 in Northeast Cobb and District 1 in North Cobb have been invited to attend. Cobb County Civic Coalition, Cobb commission candidates forum

The forum lasts from 7-9 p.m. and will be held on the second floor of the Cobb government building, 100 Cherokee St., in downtown Marietta.

That’s the meeting room for the Cobb Board of Commissioners, and if you can’t attend the forum it will be shown on the Cobb government access channel, TV 23 for Comcast subscribers.

The District 3 seat is being contested in both parties. Republican incumbent JoAnn Birrell is seeking her third term.

She is being opposed by Tom Cheek, a civic activist who filed ethics complaints against former Cobb commission chairman Tim Lee for his handling of the Atlanta Braves stadium deal. A software account manager, Cheek is a first-time candidate for public office.

On the Democratic side, two first-time candidates are running as well: retired Cobb water system employee James Smith, and Caroline Holko, a stay-at-home mother.

Here are the District 3 candidates websites:

Advance voting for the primaries begins on Monday, and Cobb Elections is looking for poll workers to help out on May 22 and beyond.

Here’s a rundown on East Cobb-area public offices that will be on the ballot, and we’ll have more shortly on those races that have contested primaries.

 

Get Our Free E-Mail Newsletter!

Every Sunday we round up the week’s top headlines and preview the upcoming week in the East Cobb News Digest. Click here to sign up, and you’re good to go!